Probationary period review checklist template
Decide, document and communicate the end of probation. Free for Canadian employers. Fill in the [HIGHLIGHTED] blanks and remove anything that doesn't apply.
Table 1: Checklist Identification and Record Control
| Checklist Title | Applies To | Completed By (Name / Title) | Date | Location / Department | Reviewed By | Review Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Probationary Period Review Checklist | [EMPLOYEE_NAME] / [JOB_TITLE] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | [EFFECTIVE_DATE] | [WORK_LOCATION] | [OWNER_OR_MANAGER] | [EFFECTIVE_DATE] |
How to Use This Checklist
Complete this checklist sequentially across the employee's probationary period ([PROBATION_PERIOD]). Do not skip phases or advance milestones until previous verification items are marked complete. Every item requires a selected status: Complete, Not Complete, or N/A. Selecting "N/A" requires an explanatory rationale recorded in the Notes column. If an item fails or is marked "Not Complete", the supervisor must immediately log the finding in Section 4 (Exceptions and Corrective Actions) and notify [OWNER_OR_MANAGER].
1. Scope & Owner
1.1 Scope
This checklist applies to all newly hired or promoted personnel subject to a probationary review period under [ORGANIZATION_NAME] within [PROVINCE].
1.2 Responsibility and Ownership
The primary operational owner is [SUPERVISOR_TITLE], responsible for conducting reviews, logging objective evidence, and meeting timeline milestones. Final determination authority rests with [OWNER_OR_MANAGER].
2. Required Checks
2.1 Phase 1: Initial Setup and Expectation Setting (Days 1–14)
Table 2: Phase 1 Verification Checks
| # | Verification Item | Required Evidence | Responsible | Status (Complete / Not Complete / N/A) | Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Confirm signed employment contract and job description are on file. | Signed contract in [FILE_LOCATION] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Mandatory prior to onboarding. | ||
| 2 | Align role duties with standardized occupational criteria. | Documented [NOC_CODE] profile | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Confirmed core duties baseline. | ||
| 3 | Deliver and document role-specific performance expectations and key metrics. | Written performance standard sheet | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Reviewed with employee. | ||
| 4 | Confirm completion of occupational health, safety, and workplace orientation. | Signed orientation sign-off sheet | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Complete in first week. | ||
| 5 | Assess and document any required workplace accommodation needs. | Accommodation plan or intake note | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | No accommodation requested. | ||
| 6 | Schedule probationary check-in milestones in mutual calendar. | Calendar invitations accepted | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | 30, 60, and final dates set. | ||
| 7 | Create employee profile and tracking milestone entry in [HRIS_NAME]. | Active profile in [HRIS_NAME] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Probation end date flagged. |
2.2 Phase 2: Mid-Point Performance Review (Mid-Probation)
Table 3: Phase 2 Verification Checks
| # | Verification Item | Required Evidence | Responsible | Status (Complete / Not Complete / N/A) | Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | Conduct formal mid-point performance feedback meeting. | Meeting notes signed by both parties | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Structured review. | ||
| 9 | Evaluate progress against core technical duties and job milestones. | Work sample evaluation log | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Measured against standards. | ||
| 10 | Evaluate workplace conduct, reliability, and team communication. | Documented supervisor assessment | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Assessed across shift logs. | ||
| 11 | Identify any training gaps or operational barriers requiring correction. | Documented skill-gap assessment | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Retraining assigned if needed. | ||
| 12 | Record employee feedback, comments, and resource requests. | Employee comments section filled | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Employee acknowledged targets. | ||
| 13 | Issue written mid-point summary to employee within [N_BUSINESS_DAYS]. | Email confirmation or signed memo | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Copy provided to employee. | ||
| 14 | Log mid-point completion status and performance notes in [HRIS_NAME]. | Updated milestone in [HRIS_NAME] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Saved to digital record. |
2.3 Phase 3: Final Assessment and Evidence Compilation (Final 30 Days)
Table 4: Phase 3 Verification Checks
| # | Verification Item | Required Evidence | Responsible | Status (Complete / Not Complete / N/A) | Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15 | Compile objective performance records, work logs, and error rates. | Performance evidence dossier | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Direct metric comparison. | ||
| 16 | Verify assessment objectivity against prohibited bias criteria. | Review evaluation rubric | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Ensure fair evaluation. | ||
| 17 | Review attendance and punctuality records against position requirements. | Timesheet reports from [PAYROLL_SYSTEM] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | No unexplained absences. | ||
| 18 | Verify accommodation efficacy if an accommodation plan exists. | Accommodation progress log | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | No plan active. | ||
| 19 | Complete comprehensive draft evaluation report and scoring. | Completed evaluation template | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Drafted for final meeting. | ||
| 20 | Conduct final probationary review interview with employee. | Formal review meeting record | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Review results discussed. | ||
| 21 | Obtain signed employee acknowledgment on final evaluation form. | Signed evaluation form | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Signature captured. |
2.4 Phase 4: Final Determination and Administrative Closeout
Table 5: Phase 4 Verification Checks
| # | Verification Item | Required Evidence | Responsible | Status (Complete / Not Complete / N/A) | Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 | Formulate final recommendation: confirmation, extension, or release. | Written recommendation form | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Forwarded to owner. | ||
| 23 | Verify employment standards obligations if separation occurs. | Statutory compliance review note | [OWNER_OR_MANAGER] | Action only if terminating. | ||
| 24 | Submit complete assessment file to [OWNER_OR_MANAGER] for approval. | Transmittal email / sign-off | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Approval requested. | ||
| 25 | Issue formal written outcome letter to employee before period expires. | Signed outcome letter | [OWNER_OR_MANAGER] | Confirmation delivered. | ||
| 26 | Update employment status and pay scale if applicable in [PAYROLL_SYSTEM]. | System update confirmation | [OWNER_OR_MANAGER] | Payroll records adjusted. | ||
| 27 | Secure personal assessment data in locked file or vault. | Safeguarded file in [FILE_LOCATION] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Privacy control verified. | ||
| 28 | Archive completed review dossier in [HRIS_NAME]. | Upload receipt in [HRIS_NAME] | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Audit trail finalized. |
3. Evidence & Records
3.1 Records Retention and Safeguards
All evidence gathered during the probationary review must be maintained in the employee's official confidential personnel file at [FILE_LOCATION]. Organizational privacy controls must protect performance scores, evaluations, and health-related accommodations against unauthorized access.
Table 6: Required Record Schedule
| Record Item | Storage Location | Access Level | Retention Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| Signed Job Expectation Sheet | [FILE_LOCATION] | Supervisor / Management | [RETENTION_PERIOD] |
| Mid-Point Review Summary | [FILE_LOCATION] | Supervisor / Management | [RETENTION_PERIOD] |
| Final Evaluation Dossier | [FILE_LOCATION] | Owner / Management | [RETENTION_PERIOD] |
| Formal Outcome Notification Letter | [FILE_LOCATION] | Owner / Management | [RETENTION_PERIOD] |
4. Exceptions & Corrective Actions
Table 7: Exceptions and Corrective Action Log
| Item # | Exception / Finding | Root Cause | Corrective Action | Owner | Target Date | Closed Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 | Inadequate software proficiency | Lack of initial system training | Schedule 3 hours of supervised tooling review | [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | [EFFECTIVE_DATE] | [EFFECTIVE_DATE] |
5. Final Sign-off
5.1 Attestation
The undersigned confirm that the probationary review process for [EMPLOYEE_NAME] was conducted objectively, in compliance with applicable employment standards, without prohibited bias, and that all required verification items and records have been completed.
5.2 Signatures
Preparer (Immediate Supervisor):
Name: [SUPERVISOR_TITLE]
Signature: ____
Date: [EFFECTIVEDATE]
Reviewer / Approver:
Name: [OWNER_OR_MANAGER]
Signature: ____
Date: [EFFECTIVEDATE]
5.3 Retention Note
The completed checklist and all supporting evidentiary records must be filed immediately in [FILE_LOCATION] and retained for [RETENTION_PERIOD] following the conclusion of employment.
What to fill in
| Placeholder | What to enter | Who provides it | Required? |
|---|---|---|---|
| [EMPLOYEE_NAME] | Full legal name of the employee under review | Hiring Manager / HR | Yes |
| [JOB_TITLE] | Official job title of the position | Hiring Manager | Yes |
| [SUPERVISOR_TITLE] | Title of the direct evaluating supervisor | Management | Yes |
| [EFFECTIVE_DATE] | Date of checklist execution or milestone completion | Supervisor | Yes |
| [WORK_LOCATION] | Physical or remote work location | Management | Yes |
| [OWNER_OR_MANAGER] | Title of the business owner or primary operational manager | Management | Yes |
| [PROBATION_PERIOD] | Length of probation (e.g., 3 months, 90 days) | Employment Contract | Yes |
| [ORGANIZATION_NAME] | Operating name of the employer | Management | Yes |
| [PROVINCE] | Canadian province or territory of employment | Management | Yes |
| [NOC_CODE] | National Occupational Classification code for the position | Hiring Manager | Yes |
| [FILE_LOCATION] | Secure digital or physical storage location for HR files | Management | Yes |
| [HRIS_NAME] | Name of the HR information system or tracking spreadsheet | Management | Yes |
| [N_BUSINESS_DAYS] | Number of business days to issue written feedback | Management | Yes |
| [PAYROLL_SYSTEM] | Name of the payroll and wage management system | Management / Bookkeeper | Yes |
| [RETENTION_PERIOD] | Record retention duration required for employment records | Management | Yes |
Official sources
Government and professional sources this template was checked against.
- Government of Canada — Federal Labour Standards
- National Occupational Classification
- Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada — Security Self-Assessment
- ISO — Diversity and Inclusion
- CIPD — Recruitment Resources
This template is general information for Canadian employers, not legal advice. Employment standards, human rights and privacy rules differ by province. Check them before you use it.
Hire people, not paperwork
Staffkin runs the whole hire in one place: prescreens, scored interviews, one-click reference checks and onboarding checklists. Free for your first job.
Start free